Building an Argument, step by step
An argument is not an opinion loudly stated. It is a claim with support and an answer to the other side.
- CLAIMYour position, in one arguable sentence.
- EVIDENCEFacts, data or quotations. Cite where they came from.
- REASONINGExplain how the evidence supports the claim. Do not assume it is obvious.
- COUNTERCLAIMState the strongest objection fairly, not a weak version of it.
- REBUTTALExplain why the objection does not defeat your claim.
If nobody could reasonably disagree with your claim, it is a fact, not an argument.
Questions about the Building an Argument poster
- What’s on the Building an Argument poster?
- 5 numbered steps. An argument is not an opinion loudly stated. It is a claim with support and an answer to the other side. CLAIM — Your position, in one arguable sentence.; EVIDENCE — Facts, data or quotations. Cite where they came from.; REASONING — Explain how the evidence supports the claim. Do not assume it is obvious.; COUNTERCLAIM — State the strongest objection fairly, not a weak version of it.; REBUTTAL — Explain why the objection does not defeat your claim.. If nobody could reasonably disagree with your claim, it is a fact, not an argument.
- Who is the Building an Argument poster for?
- Building an Argument is filed under 6th Grade (ages 11–12), so it matches what that year asks a child to remember. It is equally useful to an older student revisiting literacy, and to the parent or teacher answering the question at the kitchen table.
- When should you use the Building an Argument poster?
- The counterclaim paragraph is where the marks are. Write it deliberately. A wall chart earns its place by being glanceable from where the work is happening, so Building an Argument belongs on the wall where that literacy work actually happens, within glancing distance, rather than filed away.
- What other posters go with Building an Argument?
- Central Idea, Comma & Punctuation Rules and Alliteration sit alongside Building an Argument in the 6th Grade set. Printed together they make a wall rather than a single sheet, which is how a reference set actually gets used.Central IdeaComma & Punctuation RulesAlliteration
- Is the Building an Argument poster free to download and print?
- Yes. Building an Argument downloads as a free PDF with no account, no email and no watermark, like everything else in the 6th Grade set. Print as many copies as you like for a home, a classroom, a library or a tutoring group; reselling the file is the only thing the licence rules out.Read the licence
- What size does the Building an Argument poster print at?
- Building an Argument is a vector PDF laid out for US Letter, and prints on A4 with Fit to page — the same file, no separate download. Because every mark on it is drawn rather than photographed, it stays sharp enlarged to A3, A2 or A1 at a copy shop. Colour carries emphasis only, so a greyscale print of Building an Argument loses nothing.Printing guide
Related posters
Charts that sit alongside Building an Argument on the same wall.
Browse every 6th Grade poster, or start from the full catalogue.